Saint Maud (2019)

*. It’s probably not fair to any movie to want to stick it in a genre box, or compare it to similar movies. But . . . that’s what I like to do.
*. I even like to do it with a lot of the new wave of art-house horror flicks. I appreciate that they’re trying to do something different, but even when successful I’m finding these productions starting to look and even more sound more and more the same. For example, I really liked the score here by Adam Janota Bzowski, but boy the louring base that feels like it’s bottoming out somewhere in the depths of the ocean sounds like a lot of horror movies these days.
*. Anyway, I started off watching Saint Maud and was thinking of the sub-genre of nurse horror (type film Misery, recent example Alleluia). This was when Katie/Maud (Morfydd Clark) takes up a job as a private homecare nurse to the dying Amanda (Jennifer Erle). We sense something isn’t right with Maud, and there are mutterings about how, like Annie in Misery, she has something hidden in her past that caused her to lose her last job. So much for vetting the help. But then, homecare is a desperate market.
*. From there, however, things quickly spin into female breakdown horror (type film Repulsion, recent example Darling). Maud is a newly-minted religious nut — her friend is taken by surprise at the Catholic kitsch she keeps in her room — though we never see her reading or hear her quoting anything from the Bible. She casts an unapproving eye on Amanda’s hedonistic parties and ends up getting fired. But this only makes her more determined to effect Amanda’s redemption.
*. But while I think these are operative genres, writer-director Rose Glass doesn’t lean into them. Apparently Glass originally planned to make Maud more of a Carrie figure, victim of a strict religious upbringing, “but it just felt like a story I’d seen before, and it wasn’t one I was particularly interested in retelling.” So we have to just take her as given.
*. Some people might like this open-endedness, but for me it led to the question of where Maud was coming from. A lot of critics, most notably Mark Kermode, who called this his favourite film of the year, declared that Saint Maud wasn’t a horror movie but a movie about loneliness. Well, sure. Amanda even calls Maud the loneliest girl she’s ever seen. But where did that loneliness come from? She’s young, good-looking, educated, and has no trouble making friends.

*. So what caused her breakdown? A flashback suggests that she failed to save a dying patient when her attempt at CPR didn’t work. But how often does CPR work? And isn’t this a rather fragile response from a nurse? Amanda’s new caregiver has a more realistic attitude toward death: “that’s the way the cookie crumbles.” I get that Maud doesn’t want to accept this, but then she’s in the wrong profession.
*. Accepting that Glass simply isn’t interested in how Maud got here, what is she interested in? I think the answer is faith, which leads me to the movie that Saint Maud most reminded me of: Paul Schrader’s First Reformed. There are obvious resemblances in the levitation scene and the (imagined) act of self-destruction at the end, but more than that there’s a deeper exploration of the consequences of being a believer.
*. Unfortunately for Saint Maud, it doesn’t hold a candle to what Schrader did in developing this theme. Glass settles for a lazier conclusion. Unless I’m missing something, the point here is that faith is a lie and believers are dangerous psychotics. If you hear God talking to you, chances are you’re just listening to voices in your head. A point made pretty clear here because God speaks in Welsh and his voice is actually Clark’s with the pitch lowered.
*. As I say, this is unfortunate. I think Saint Maud is a really good film. Glass sets the mood well and the two leads are great. I was disappointed that Erle didn’t have a larger part, but I can’t say enough about Clark. This is a real career-making role. I was surprised when looking over her filmography to see that she’d been in two previous movies I’d reviewed — Pride and Prejudice and Zombies and Crawl — and hadn’t registered at all. Well, maybe not that surprised.
*. Worth seeing, and a movie that can be enjoyed if you forget about some of the hype and don’t think you’re seeing a horror flick or even a particularly taut psychological thriller. On the other hand, if it’s something more, what is it?

21 thoughts on “Saint Maud (2019)

  1. film-authority.com

    The hype killed this for me; I thought it was just another horror film, and with not much to say over 80 mins. Can’t imagine why this would be anyone’s favourite film of the year. Next!

    Reply
    1. Alex Good Post author

      Kermode’s picks for best of the year are weird. He thought Raw was the best movie of 2017 and it was just a cute little movie with a gag ending. This one felt like it could have been more, but it doesn’t know what to do with Maud aside from making her another religious nutjob.

      Reply
  2. Bookstooge

    God told me to tell you to tell the director that He isn’t very happy with this movie. He also stated that He’s ordering St Peter to set a new standard for getting into Heaven. Instead of asking you if you like kittens or rainbows or something, St. Peter will now ask if you’ve ever made a movie. If you have, straight to hell you go! God takes this whole movie thing pretty seriously. I know, because He told me so…

    Reply
      1. Bookstooge

        There are plenty of help-wanted signs at Mcdonalds and other fast food places. Heck, one of the Subway Sandwich shops in our town shut down because they didn’t have anyone to work there 😦 and it was the one closest to us too, double sad face…..

      2. Bookstooge

        Yeah, every time they hired someone new, we had to train them all over to make our sandwiches the way we liked them. It was a lot of work, especially as a paying customer…

      3. Alex Good Post author

        I always liked the newbies who didn’t know how much meat they were supposed to put in so they always ended up giving you double. But they usually got fired after a week.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.